Paper Pages

Anyone who knows me even a little bit knows that I love books. Get to know me a bit better and you’ll know that I am what is known as a “reader.” Get to know me even beyond that and you’ll discover that I have a … distaste … for e-readers.

However, in the month of March I had decided I enjoyed the book club quite a lot in February, and they were reading a book I’d been interested in for a while, and I managed to get in on it at the beginning of the month when the book was offered for free by the author. So I thought, “Hey, I’ll save some money and read this one on my iPad!”

It was the first time I’d ever read a full e-book on an e-reading device (and I have since been told that I picked the wrong device for this experiment, but I do not own any other options). I have read books on my computer for ARC and editing and beta-reading purposes… but I do not do that very often because I dislike it so very much. But in this case, I thought perhaps it would be good to at least try reading an e-book. That way, if I hated the experience, at least I could say that I’d tried. Right?

The problems with reading an ebook are many.

1. The thing is awkwardly shaped for holding. I have mastered the art of holding a book, even a big hardback book like “The Aeronaut’s Windlass” in one hand, and can even manage to flip the pages that way. This is not possible on the iPad. It is a 2-handed operation, which is annoying. I read so fast and the screen is so small, that switching from one hand to two in order to advance the pages didn’t make sense, so it had to be held a very specific way with two hands.

2. I use a very different part of my brain when reading words on a screen versus reading words on paper. It is a bit difficult for me to remember much about the book: names, events, etc… where I do not usually have that problem when reading.

3. The light from the screen was hard on my eyes and often gave me a headache. (Apparently this does not happen with other e-readers, but I can’t speak to them)

4. The iPad often had a hard time saving the page I bookmarked to stop at. This made finding my spot difficult at times, which took up precious reading time that I will never get back.

5. I don’t like seeing random dotted underlines of quotes other people liked, and I have no idea how to turn that off so I don’t see it.

6. When I am reading a paper-pages book, none of my children try to take it from me so they can play games on it or watch Netflix. This is definitely a deal-breaker for me.

7. No paper smell. I know this is probably a bit on the silly side, but it didn’t smell like a book.

8. When something awesome happened, or when the book ended… I couldn’t “hug” it… I mean, I could, but the iPad is cold and a bit standoffish.

9. If something awful happens, you can’t throw it across the room. (I don’t throw books as a general rule, but sometimes it’s warranted, and you just can’t do that with something you’ve paid hundreds of dollars for).

10. I didn’t like not being able to see my progress or easily gauge how far I had left to read. The little “you are on 66894573 out of 1111223304058587474″ makes little sense to me, and the percentage number was highly dissatisfying.

11. The thing is COLD! Setting it on my knees was not an option if I was wearing shorts!

12. Our iPad is old, okay? So if it was out of battery, I had to plug it in and wait a good 5-10 minutes before it had enough juice to turn on so I could start reading my book.

13. If I ever meet the author, I can’t have him sign my copy…

All of this just adds up to one thing. I’m going to stick with paper pages. Some of these complaints may be addressed by getting a different device, but not all of them. However, all of these issues are solved by just picking up a good, old-fashioned, book.

 

How about you, dear Reader? Do you have an ereader you really love? Do you prefer paper pages? Let me know in the comments!

~ jenelle

10 Comments

Nancy Walker

I agree with you totally! The ONE and basically only one reason I use my Kindle is when it really is more convenient to travel with instead of several big bags of books. :) I can bring along quite a large “library” of reading material within my one device. But once I get home, it’s back to the “paper pages.” :)

Reply
jenelle

It does make taking a stack o’ books on vacation easier. But in my experience, I don’t tend to read a lot on vacation… I am too busy doing other fun things… or corralling children. So… one or two books max is about all I ever need to take with me. Not too hard to find space for those in my luggage! :)

Reply
E.F.B.

Literally everything you mentioned here is the reason I haven’t bothered with e-readers. I prefer my paper books any day. The only positive I can see about e-readers is the occasional free book and the travel convenience, but I rarely travel and can just as easily get free paper books at the library, sooooo… :)

Reply
jenelle

I’m so glad I’m not the only one!

Libraries are the BEST! And for the indie authors I read… I don’t mind paying a little extra to get their paperback version. The only time I ever “miss” having an ereader is when a book comes out that I love the sound of… only to find out it’s only available in e-version.

Reply
Christine

YESSSS. I 100% agree with all of this!

I do actually end up reading a lot of ebooks. Because, well, I can’t resist a free book, so I have a ton on my Kindle app. And often people will give me an ebook for review or something. But…ugh. I don’t like it. And I can’t read too many ebooks at once. I recently read an ebook and then a novella on my kindle soon after, and by the end of it all I was sooooo tired of reading on my tablet. I wanted a real BOOK. I spend enough of my life as a writer having to stare at a screen. Reading gives me a chance to take a break from that.

Real books > ebooks ALWAYS.

(And I sooo related to your point about not being able to hug the book. If I read something I love, I just want to hug it, but hugging my cold, metal tablet is just awkward…)

Reply
jenelle

YES! Writer = Lots of Screen Time Already. I should have listed that in my reasons. Getting away from the screen is so nice. This is also why parts of my outlines/rough drafts sometimes happen in actual notebooks! Sometimes the only way to break through writer’s block is to pick up a pen and do it the old-fashioned way!

Haha, yes, hugging a tablet is weird. I wanted to a couple of times while reading Dragonfriend… but… it wasn’t the same. Had I been reading a book any less stellar, I probably would have given up… but doggone it, that’s a good book!

Reply
Madeline J. Rose

YESNESS. Yes to ALL of these!

And even with the e-readers, I’ve found that they still hurt my eyes, even with the special dimming light system. It’s really hard to read it at night. Even though it glows, I always read it with the light on. XD

And of course…Can’t beat that paper smell. ;)

Reply
jenelle

Good to know about them being hard to read at night and needing the light on anyway.

Paper smells good! I especially love the old book smell and the visions of what adventures that book has been on with other readers.

Reply

I love hearing from you, dear Reader!